The Kenshin Ryu Campaign, Scenarios 2 and 3: Ambush and Duel

So, here's a turn-up for the books!

Unfortunately, Gareth was ill last week, but this week his son Tim turned up as well, so they ended up splitting between them: Gareth and I would play through the Assassination scenario to give Tim a chance to re-familiarise himself with the rules, and then Tim would take the Koryu for the Duel.

Game 2 was... well it certainly was something. Owing to the En Garde points changes, the ninja force comprised six men rather than the five from the original scenario, and I chose to deploy four to begin with, with two held in reserve to try and stop the Sensei's advance. This, er, did not work out quite to my advantage. My Ninjas all had a less than stellar performance in melée against all the lesser figures, and one was completely swept aside by the Sensei. Right at the end, I managed to win a critical Priority roll and close in with my Chunin... who proceeded to be cut to pieces almost immediately. This left a single Ninja to flee the field in terror.









The less said about Game 3 the better. My plan had been to get some forces in position to do some damage to the Senpai should things go a bit inauspiciously in the duel. Turns out, 'a bit inauspiciously' meant my Leader dying in the first round of melée, leaving all of my troops horrendously out of position and surrounded by hostile Koryu figures. I managed to pull three men out, and my musketeer heroically took down a Koryu Kouhai before being himself cut down (the only Koryu casualty of the entire game), for a decidedly disastrous continuation.






In the end, across the two scenarios, the Bandits had a mere four survivors: one Ninja, one Gashira, and two Bandits. Points-wise, this did not look very good for them, but I was not exactly in a good enough mood to do the maths on this, and decided to focus simply on congratulating my opponents in public while plotting my vengeance in private...

Having more than reversed the losses from Scenario 1, and with the Koryu up 6 points with both a surviving Sensei and having firm control of the scrolls... let's say I'll be asking Gareth very nicely if I can have some more reinforcements ahead of Scenarios 4+5...

One thing I am wondering is whether the original scenario concept, particularly for scenario 3, may have been flawed. 2 was a close-run thing but the fault was mostly my own for overcommitting to piecemeal attacks rather than running people off the field. In 3, however, I have to admit that I find it hard to see how the duel in the centre is not biased against the Bandits to a pretty considerable degree. Irrespective of the Leader's armour, they have a pretty noticeable disadvantage against the Senpai. Firstly, the difference in Fight values flattens out each side's disparities in defence: the 1 disparity in Fight values means that the Leader rolls at -1 against him when attacking, while the Senpai rolls at -2 against the Leader instead of the -3 that the Leader would have against an equal Fight model. Then, the Senpai gets an extra Attack or Defence token which more or less compels the Leader to adopt a more defensive posture. And, if you include the Intuition attribute – as Gareth quite sensibly chose – the Senpai now has five tokens to play with even if one has to be a Defence.

So, er, yes. I am not happy about Game 3.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Capture the Crossroads – 7 September 2023

Image
Despite having played The Men Who Would be Kings for a couple of years now, it struck me that I had never got round to trying its much-vaunted solo rules. With my normal sparring partners unavailable and some bad weather rolling in, I thought it would be a good chance to have a go, and also to break in some of my Anglo-Indian forces. The game lasted a whopping 29 turns so I'll try not to do a complete blow-by-blow; instead I'll try to give a relatively general summary of what happened, and my thoughts on the Mr Babbage system. To get a criticism out of the way early on, how exactly to set up is not as clearly communicated as it might have been. That you should ideally just be playing a pure combat encounter rather than a scored scenario is the last of Mr Babbage's ten instructions, and when you are told to 'line your chaps up' you are not told whether to do so lengthways or widthways. Taking a cue from this solo game by Neil of the blog Toy Soldiers and Dining Room
Read more

The Anglo-Indian Intervention Force in Japan, Part One (Indian Infantry)

Image
For reasons I can no longer really work out, I decided, just as I was starting to build up some decently sized Japanese forces for the 1868-9 Boshin War, that a fun additional project would be doing some British and French expeditionary forces. Should I ever finish the British one, it alone will probably number almost as much as both my Imperial and Shogunate armies put together. Logically of course, that means the latter two ought to be enlarged... Questionable decisions aside, it's something that I've made fits and starts on in the last year, and that I now feel I ought to make a more determined push on. So, this first post will document the one complete element of these forces so far, that being the Indian infantry, and hopefully that spurs me on to get the rest of these finished in the coming months. The decision to field Indian troops in this force was made for three reasons. Firstly, why not? Secondly, the hypothetical structure of my expeditionary force was based on a sl
Read more

Comparing Skirmish Rules for the Boshin War

Image
Being a bit of a prolific collector of rules, I thought I'd procrastinate a bit on finishing off various other projects in order to go over the ones I've used for the Boshin War over the last few years. To just lay things out in advance, I think all of these rules work both about equally well as games in their own right and for the Boshin War in particular, even if there are a couple I gravitate more towards than others. What I will do in this post is run very quickly through each set of rules on its own (on the off-chance that any given reader is unfamiliar, but I suspect that's only likely to be true of one of these rule sets), then cover how they, or supplemental material, cover the Boshin War, or can be made to. At present this post only covers four sets of rules, but that could go up over time as I try adapting other sets for use with the period (I'm already eyeing Test of Honour  and Bushidan , for instance). Sharp Practice (2nd edition) (TooFatLardies, 2016) Shar
Read more